Benjamin E. Valentine was born circa 1841 in Ohio. He died in 1883 in Ohio.
Benjamin married Clara Elder in 1869 in Coshocton County, Ohio. Clara Elder (Parents) was born on 23 May 1844 in Ohio. She died in 1885 in Ohio.
M
i
Arthur Valentine was born in 1872 in Coshocton County, Ohio. He died in 1911 in Tennessee.
F
ii
Josephine A. Valentine was born in 1874 in Coshocton County, Ohio. She died on 9 Feb 1927 in Tennessee.
F
iii
Matilda E. Valentine was born in 1876 in Ohio. She died on 30 Aug 1933 in Decatur County, Tennessee.
M
iv
Theodore H. Valentine was born about 1876 in Ohio. He died on 10 Feb 1943 in Decatur County, Tennessee.
M
v
George S. Valentine was born in 1879 in Ohio. He died on 6 Jun 1937 in Decatur County, Tennessee.